Hiring the wrong renovation contractor in Ontario is the most expensive renovation mistake you can make. Not because of the contractor’s quote — but because of what happens after the contract is signed: missed deadlines, unpermitted work, hidden costs, and in the worst cases, a contractor who disappears mid-project.
This guide tells you exactly how to find, vet, and hire a reliable renovation contractor in Ontario — based on what separates good projects from disasters.
Step 1: Verify Licensing and Insurance Before Anything Else
In Ontario, general contractors are not licensed by a provincial body the way electricians and plumbers are. However, the trades working on your project must be licensed — and the general contractor must carry proper insurance. Here’s what to verify:
- General Liability Insurance: Minimum $2 million per occurrence. Ask for a current certificate of insurance naming you as an additional insured. This protects you if a worker is injured on your property or your home is damaged.
- WSIB Coverage: Workers’ Compensation coverage for all workers on site. Without it, you can be held liable for injuries to workers on your property. Request a current WSIB clearance certificate.
- Licensed Trades: Any electrical work must be done by an ESA-registered electrician (verify at esa.on.ca). Plumbing must be done by an Ontario-licensed plumber. Structural work with permits requires code compliance.
- HSN (Harmonized Sales Number): Any contractor billing more than $30,000/year must be HST-registered. Get their HST number and verify it at Canada Revenue Agency’s website. A contractor asking for cash to avoid HST is a red flag.
Step 2: Get 3 Itemized Written Quotes
The most common mistake Ontario homeowners make when hiring a contractor is comparing quotes that aren’t actually comparable. One quote includes all trades and materials; another excludes electrical; a third doesn’t include disposal. You’re not comparing the same thing.
An itemized quote should break down:
- Demolition and disposal costs
- Materials (with brand/spec, not just “quartz countertops”)
- Labour by trade (framing, electrical, plumbing, tile, carpentry, painting)
- Permit fees (who applies, who pays)
- Project management fee (usually 15–25% for a GC)
- HST
- Contingency allowance (or clearly stated exclusions)
If a contractor won’t give you an itemized quote, don’t hire them. A contractor who can’t break down their price doesn’t have control of their costs — and you’ll be the one paying for that when change orders arrive.
Step 3: Check Reviews — In the Right Places
Google reviews are the most trustworthy source because they’re tied to real Google accounts and harder to manipulate. HomeStars is second — HomeStars verifies that reviewers are real homeowners. Facebook reviews are third. Houzz is useful for portfolio verification.
What to look for:
- Volume: A contractor with 50+ reviews is more reliable than one with 8.
- Recency: Check that reviews include work done in the last 12 months — a company can deteriorate.
- Specificity: Reviews that mention specific trades, timelines, or project types are real. “Great job!” reviews without details are often fake.
- How complaints are handled: One negative review in 50 is normal. A contractor who responds professionally is a better sign than a contractor with zero negative reviews (which is suspicious).
- Photos: Look for before/after photos on Google, HomeStars, or Houzz that match the type of work you’re having done.
Step 4: Ask These Questions Before Signing
Ask every contractor you’re seriously considering these questions. A good contractor answers clearly. A bad contractor hedges, deflects, or can’t answer.
- “Who specifically will be working in my home?” Will the work be done by in-house employees or subcontractors? If subcontractors: do they carry their own WSIB and insurance?
- “Who pulls the permits?” For any work requiring a permit, the contractor should pull it — not the homeowner. A contractor who asks you to pull your own permit is trying to shift liability.
- “What is your warranty?” Get the warranty in writing. One year on workmanship is industry standard. Longer is better.
- “How do you handle change orders?” Changes must be in writing, signed, and priced before work proceeds. Any contractor who makes changes verbally and adds them to the final invoice is going to be a problem.
- “Can you provide 3 references from projects completed in the last 6 months?” Any reputable contractor can provide this immediately. Call the references — actually call them, don’t just email.
- “What is your payment schedule?” See the payment section below.
Step 5: Understand the Contract — Before You Sign
A legitimate renovation contract should include:
- Fixed price (not a range) — or a clearly defined allowance system with written change order process
- Detailed scope of work matching what was in the quote
- Material specifications — brand, model, colour, grade
- Start and completion dates (these are estimates, but they should be in writing)
- Payment schedule tied to project milestones, not calendar dates
- Warranty terms in writing
- Dispute resolution process
- Permit responsibility — who applies, who pays fees, who manages inspections
Payment Schedule — The Rule of Thirds
The payment structure is one of the clearest signals of a contractor’s legitimacy.
Standard Ontario renovation payment schedule:
- Deposit (10–20%): Due at contract signing. Covers initial material deposits and scheduling.
- Progress payments (40–50%): Tied to specific project milestones (demolition complete, rough-in complete, cabinets installed, etc.).
- Holdback (10%): This is your legal right in Ontario. Under the Construction Act, homeowners can withhold 10% of each payment as a lien holdback for 45 days after project completion.
- Final payment: Due after your final walkthrough and sign-off, not before.
Red flags in payment requests: Any contractor asking for 50%+ upfront, cash only payments, full payment before completion, or who can’t explain why they need the deposit amount they’re asking for.
Red Flags — Walk Away From These
- No written contract or insists on a handshake deal
- Can’t provide insurance or WSIB certificates immediately
- Quote is dramatically lower than the other two (they’ve missed something, will find it later)
- Asks you to pull your own permits
- Can’t provide recent references
- Asks for more than 30% deposit before work starts
- No fixed office address or online presence
- Pressures you to sign immediately (“I have a cancellation this week”)
- Wants to be paid in cash (usually HST evasion)
What a Good Renovation Contractor Looks Like
A reputable renovation contractor in Ontario will:
- Provide insurance and WSIB certificates on request, same day
- Give you an itemized written quote within 3–5 business days of the site visit
- Have 30+ Google or HomeStars reviews with a rating above 4.5
- Pull all required permits and manage all inspections
- Use a written contract with fixed pricing and clear milestone payments
- Answer your questions directly, without deflection
- Provide a written warranty (minimum 1 year)
Frequently Asked Questions — Choosing a Renovation Contractor Ontario
Do I need a licensed contractor for home renovation in Ontario?
General contractors are not provincially licensed in Ontario, but the trades working on your project must be licensed. Electricians must be ESA-registered. Plumbers must be licensed. Any contractor doing structural, electrical, or plumbing work who uses unlicensed trades is exposing you to liability and code violations.
How many quotes should I get for a renovation in Ontario?
At least 3 itemized written quotes. Not for the purpose of automatically picking the cheapest — but to understand the realistic cost range and to compare what each contractor is including or excluding. The cheapest quote is usually the one that has excluded the most.
What should a renovation contract include in Ontario?
Fixed price or clearly defined allowances, detailed scope, material specifications, start and completion dates, payment schedule tied to milestones, warranty terms, permit responsibility, and change order process. Never sign a contract without these elements in writing.
Get a Free Renovation Estimate from Mila 4 Renovation
We’re a licensed, WSIB-insured renovation contractor serving Milton, Mississauga, Oakville, and Burlington since 2008. We provide itemized written quotes, pull all permits, and carry full insurance and WSIB coverage on every project.
Call 647-280-7780 or request a free estimate online.
Related: Kitchen Renovation Milton | Bathroom Renovation Milton | Basement Renovation Milton